The scandal foto oscar in the US. Anti-Polish film from Emmy - Wykop.pl foto oscar
Duplicate added: fir3fly of wykop.pl
@ Filipix: Specifically, it is said in the film during the war, Jews have problems with Poles, not Germans. I do not see, do not want to get cancer. http://pl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nasze_matki,_nasi_ojcowie#Krytyka_i_kontrowersje
foto oscar @ Alosha: I basically only "complaint" (if you can call it that), it nieuwolnienie Jews from the train. So the lack of dedication for the Jews. Murder as such do not see. And the Army did not cherished little Jews, it is not a crime and may have good reason to be indifferent. I'm afraid that someone wants to tighten the Poles "not sacrificed his life for the Jewish foto oscar people, then you are anti-Polish".
@ Alosha: In fact, the film was shown bestiality Germans (except for a small group of friends) and the scene of Ukrainians in the murder of civilians. Although the climate could actually feel that Jews were afraid the Poles and the Poles do not trust them. I wonder why?
@ Alosha: Poles were punished with death for helping Jews, so it is hardly surprising. Although it was the scene reported that the peasant went Jew hiding at his house. In contrast, a peasant's son organized his escape to the forest.
@ LowcaAndroidow: We wrote about this scene above
And the Army did not cherished little Jews, it is not a crime and may have a good reason @ Filipix: at all what the text? As a business foto oscar unit could someone like it or not? A member of the AK said that the Army could be some anti-Semites but you can not say that AK was anti-Semitic.
@ LowcaAndroidow: foto oscar In agree. I had only to scenes from the movie. But: 1. Anti-Semitism is not anti-Polish 2. There was not even anti-Semitism, AK does not murdered Jews. On the other hand it gave out very clearly see theme whitening Germans and pointing to the Nazis as the only guilty foto oscar party. As if Germany did not support them.
On the other hand it gave out very clearly see theme whitening Germans and pointing to the Nazis as the only guilty party. As if Germany did not support them. @ Filipix: You already have a right, but that is not why the film is by some circles in Poland criticized. He is accused of presenting Poles mainly in a negative light, as anti-Semites. As if anti-Semitic attitudes among Poles did not exist. Environment criticizing the film does not allow the situation shown in him as likely to happen. These circles believe that the Pole could not afford indifference to the fate of the Jews. The film I watched with curiosity and pleasure foto oscar it deserves. It does not surprise me winning an Emmy. It's a great movie. In contrast, reaction in some circles on the movie is downright allergic and hysterical. foto oscar
@ SmutnyAndrzej: Someone is trying to equate: Anti-Semitism = anti-Polonism with this affair. For example, right-wing circles to ridicule or sort out their heads of Jewish communities Such position begs me to conclusion. Though I could be wrong
@ Filipix: recently foto oscar watched the show to yourself to see, a little bit so I wouuld foto oscar convene to convey your thoughts. Generally, as for me, this talk about the Jews are there terribly artificial and force, as if someone wrote it into the script because foto oscar Germany foto oscar for ugly falling foto oscar out. Generally there because Poles have even more depth than some of the main characters (the singer does not have such. Virtually all personality), which can be seen even after the retaliatory executions when they sit and wonder about the sense of further fighting. In contrast, anti-Semitism is not just murder Jews. Polish characters were anti-Semitic until almost comical sizes ("Jews drown like cats' foto oscar interests only if the department foto oscar does not have Jews as if something foto oscar has changed in their situation, senseless closure wagon - before they got out to the Germans to come yet," most of them that Jews "- reluctance / hatred of Jews so great that the minority are able to leave in the lurch). If the authors wanted to show that Poles so afraid of catching using it unless they failed ... As for the Germans whitening there are some "flavors" that are flips for "ordinary" Germans, but which may not be noticed if it turns attention. Eg. The narrator foto oscar says ironically something like "soon will not be here Nazis, the Germans," just this woman in the house of the family of Victor zarzekając that supposedly helped, of sturmbanfuhrerze, which is building the new Germany not to mention (There are also some allusion to USA). As for the German heroes - lack there completely wrong of these major, and their companions are just that Blondie was more fanatic, so it's just the psychopath who terrified all the ordinary soldiers, "battalion ghosts" and the branch penalty, which was supposed to fight communists and partisans, and in fact it served only to harass the main character and other kind-hearted deserters. Even some artificial transformation Friedrich (a little cynical - "war cut
Duplicate added: fir3fly of wykop.pl
@ Filipix: Specifically, it is said in the film during the war, Jews have problems with Poles, not Germans. I do not see, do not want to get cancer. http://pl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nasze_matki,_nasi_ojcowie#Krytyka_i_kontrowersje
foto oscar @ Alosha: I basically only "complaint" (if you can call it that), it nieuwolnienie Jews from the train. So the lack of dedication for the Jews. Murder as such do not see. And the Army did not cherished little Jews, it is not a crime and may have good reason to be indifferent. I'm afraid that someone wants to tighten the Poles "not sacrificed his life for the Jewish foto oscar people, then you are anti-Polish".
@ Alosha: In fact, the film was shown bestiality Germans (except for a small group of friends) and the scene of Ukrainians in the murder of civilians. Although the climate could actually feel that Jews were afraid the Poles and the Poles do not trust them. I wonder why?
@ Alosha: Poles were punished with death for helping Jews, so it is hardly surprising. Although it was the scene reported that the peasant went Jew hiding at his house. In contrast, a peasant's son organized his escape to the forest.
@ LowcaAndroidow: We wrote about this scene above
And the Army did not cherished little Jews, it is not a crime and may have a good reason @ Filipix: at all what the text? As a business foto oscar unit could someone like it or not? A member of the AK said that the Army could be some anti-Semites but you can not say that AK was anti-Semitic.
@ LowcaAndroidow: foto oscar In agree. I had only to scenes from the movie. But: 1. Anti-Semitism is not anti-Polish 2. There was not even anti-Semitism, AK does not murdered Jews. On the other hand it gave out very clearly see theme whitening Germans and pointing to the Nazis as the only guilty foto oscar party. As if Germany did not support them.
On the other hand it gave out very clearly see theme whitening Germans and pointing to the Nazis as the only guilty party. As if Germany did not support them. @ Filipix: You already have a right, but that is not why the film is by some circles in Poland criticized. He is accused of presenting Poles mainly in a negative light, as anti-Semites. As if anti-Semitic attitudes among Poles did not exist. Environment criticizing the film does not allow the situation shown in him as likely to happen. These circles believe that the Pole could not afford indifference to the fate of the Jews. The film I watched with curiosity and pleasure foto oscar it deserves. It does not surprise me winning an Emmy. It's a great movie. In contrast, reaction in some circles on the movie is downright allergic and hysterical. foto oscar
@ SmutnyAndrzej: Someone is trying to equate: Anti-Semitism = anti-Polonism with this affair. For example, right-wing circles to ridicule or sort out their heads of Jewish communities Such position begs me to conclusion. Though I could be wrong
@ Filipix: recently foto oscar watched the show to yourself to see, a little bit so I wouuld foto oscar convene to convey your thoughts. Generally, as for me, this talk about the Jews are there terribly artificial and force, as if someone wrote it into the script because foto oscar Germany foto oscar for ugly falling foto oscar out. Generally there because Poles have even more depth than some of the main characters (the singer does not have such. Virtually all personality), which can be seen even after the retaliatory executions when they sit and wonder about the sense of further fighting. In contrast, anti-Semitism is not just murder Jews. Polish characters were anti-Semitic until almost comical sizes ("Jews drown like cats' foto oscar interests only if the department foto oscar does not have Jews as if something foto oscar has changed in their situation, senseless closure wagon - before they got out to the Germans to come yet," most of them that Jews "- reluctance / hatred of Jews so great that the minority are able to leave in the lurch). If the authors wanted to show that Poles so afraid of catching using it unless they failed ... As for the Germans whitening there are some "flavors" that are flips for "ordinary" Germans, but which may not be noticed if it turns attention. Eg. The narrator foto oscar says ironically something like "soon will not be here Nazis, the Germans," just this woman in the house of the family of Victor zarzekając that supposedly helped, of sturmbanfuhrerze, which is building the new Germany not to mention (There are also some allusion to USA). As for the German heroes - lack there completely wrong of these major, and their companions are just that Blondie was more fanatic, so it's just the psychopath who terrified all the ordinary soldiers, "battalion ghosts" and the branch penalty, which was supposed to fight communists and partisans, and in fact it served only to harass the main character and other kind-hearted deserters. Even some artificial transformation Friedrich (a little cynical - "war cut
No comments:
Post a Comment